Among Monsters

Oct 1·34 min

In August 2005, 29-year-old mother of three Corina Voegeli-Burton disappeared from her home in southwestern Wisconsin. But Corina’s story didn’t begin with her disappearance. She had changed her locks, changed her phone numbers, stayed elsewhere with her children, contacted police, and sought a restraining order after threats and alleged stalking by her former boyfriend, David Carpenter. Nine days after seeking court protection, Corina was dead—and her body was discovered hidden in an abandoned mine shaft. In this episode of Among Monsters, Myia Hanson examines the warning signs, the escalating threats, the investigation, and the tragic murder of Corina Voegeli-Burton—a case that asks a haunting question: What happens when the warnings are there, but they aren't enough to stop what comes next?

Sep 24·46 min

Who Killed Lisa Collins? In January 2022, 41-year-old mother Lisa Collins was last seen in Janesville, Wisconsin. Roughly twelve hours later, she was found stabbed to death along Clary Street in Beloit. Four years later, no arrest has been announced and her family is still searching for answers. Among Monsters examines Lisa’s final known hours, the unanswered questions surrounding her journey to Beloit, and the investigation into who killed her. Someone knows what happened that night.

Sep 17·39 min

In 1997, 52-year-old diner owner Dorothy Wenzel was brutally murdered outside the West Wind Diner near Darien, Wisconsin. Within days, police arrested two teenagers and uncovered a planned robbery that ended in a deadly baseball bat attack. Nearly three decades later, confusion still surrounds how the case was solved. Among Monsters examines the crime, the confessions, the evidence, and the choices that turned an ordinary night at a small-town diner into tragedy.

Sep 10·49 min

On February 14, 2000, nine-year-old Asha Degree disappeared after leaving her North Carolina home in the middle of a cold, stormy night. Witnesses reported seeing her walking alone along Highway 18 before she vanished into the darkness. Eighteen months later, her backpack was discovered buried miles away. More than two decades later, new searches and forensic evidence have renewed attention on the case—but Asha is still missing. In this episode of Among Monsters, Jeremy Hanson examines the haunting timeline, the evidence left behind, and the unanswered question that remains: What happened to Asha Degree?

Sep 3·37 min

A stalking investigation in Wisconsin takes a horrifying turn when detectives searching Benjamin Larson’s rural home discover human skulls, skeletal remains, a mummy, serial-killer memorabilia, and a disturbing locked room. Now Larson has been arrested again as investigators race to determine where the remains came from—and what else may be hidden behind this bizarre case.

Aug 27·40 min

In this episode of Among Monsters, we revisit the heartbreaking murder of 10-year-old Lily Peters and the case against Carson Peters-Berger, who was just 14 when the crime occurred. More than four years later, Peters-Berger pleaded guilty to first-degree intentional homicide and was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of release after 25 years. We examine the crime, the long legal battle, the final sentencing—and most importantly, remember Lily and the life that was stolen from her.

Aug 20·36 min

A routine encounter near Independence Hall leads investigators to a disturbing Philadelphia home connected to multiple missing women. In this episode of Among Monsters, we explore the developing Eugene Horsch investigation, the evidence recovered from the West Chew Avenue property, and the unanswered questions surrounding Amy McHale, Blair Tonzelli, Maribel Fresses, and Gabrielle Amarando.

Aug 13·30 min

More than four years after Kenneth “Jay” Mathews was shot and killed in Joplin, Missouri, investigators finally announced a major break. A suspect is now charged with murder—but the long road from a quiet neighborhood shooting to an arrest leaves questions still unanswered. Among Monsters follows the investigation, the years of silence, and the family that never stopped waiting for answers.

Aug 6·30 min

or 38 years, the truth remained buried in silence. In this gripping episode of Among Monsters, Myia Hanson unravels the haunting case of Ronna Bremer, a 22-year-old pregnant mother who vanished just days before Christmas in 1988. As decades passed, secrets, conflicting stories, and unanswered questions kept her family waiting for justice. But when a cold case investigation uncovered new evidence, the silence finally began to break. This is the story of a life stolen, a family forever changed, and the relentless pursuit of the truth.

Jul 30·42 min

When four-year-old Derrick Robie disappeared on what should have been a short walk to summer camp in the quiet village of Savona, New York, no one imagined the truth. The person responsible wasn't a stranger or a hardened criminal—it was a 13-year-old boy named Eric Smith.In this episode of Among Monsters, Myia examines one of the most disturbing juvenile murder cases in American history. Through documented facts, court records, and investigative reporting, we explore the tragic loss of Derrick Robie, Eric Smith's troubled childhood, the investigation that stunned the nation, his controversial trial, nearly three decades behind bars, and the debate surrounding his eventual release. Above all, this episode remembers the innocent life that was taken and asks the difficult questions about childhood violence, accountability, and whether redemption is ever truly possible after an unimaginable crime.

Jul 23·38 min

In this chilling episode of Among Monsters, Myia tells the heartbreaking true story of Helen Fuller, a Wisconsin woman who desperately tried to get help before she was murdered by her husband in 1996. What began as a plea for protection ended in a horrific act of domestic violence that shocked the community and inspired a lasting legacy of hope for survivors. This powerful episode explores the warning signs of abuse, the failures that can leave victims vulnerable, and the importance of listening when someone says they're afraid.

Jul 16·28 min·Episode 31

Melissa Trumpy vanished after leaving work on October 26, 2021, and has never been seen again. In this episode of Among Monsters, Myia Vale examines the haunting timeline, troubled relationships, abandoned vehicle, and ongoing homicide investigation surrounding one of Wisconsin's most unsettling unsolved disappearances.

Jul 9·33 min·Episode 30

In this heartbreaking episode of Among Monsters, Myia Vale examines the 2007 Delavan, Wisconsin family massacre committed by Ambrosio Analco Ramirez. Through a factual, victim-centered investigation, we explore the warning signs of domestic violence, the tragic events that unfolded inside a quiet family home, and the lasting impact on a community forever changed.

Jul 2·38 min·Episode 29

At just 15 years old, Aubrey Wyatt's life came to a heartbreaking end, leaving behind a grieving family and a story that sparked a nationwide conversation. In this episode of Among Monsters, we carefully examine the documented facts surrounding Aubrey's story, the growing concerns about bullying and cyberbullying, and how social media transformed a personal tragedy into a viral national debate. Rather than repeating rumors, we focus on compassion, accountability, and the lasting impact that words can have. This is a powerful story about truth, empathy, and the importance of looking out for one another before it's too late.

Jun 25·28 min·Episode 28

In April 2019, 69-year-old Betty Alexander disappeared from her senior apartment in Sullivan, Missouri, leaving behind her purse, glasses, medication, and every sign of her daily routine. Despite extensive searches and years of investigation, no trace of Betty has ever been found. In this episode of Among Monsters, we examine the documented facts, the unanswered questions, and the family still searching for the truth.

Jun 18·16 min·Episode 27

A young man with a dream future, a SpaceX job, and a promising college career seemed to have it all. But behind the image was a web of lies that would end in one of Wisconsin's most shocking family murder cases. In this episode of Among Monsters, Myia Vale examines the chilling story of Chandler Halderson.

Jun 11·32 min·Episode 26

In this episode of Among Monsters, we examine the case of Joshua Julius Anderson, a Tulsa, Oklahoma killer who was convicted in the murders of four people during a violent three-month spree between late 2006 and early 2007. Through verified facts, court records, and investigative details, we explore how a series of seemingly unrelated killings were ultimately connected to one young man whose actions left a lasting impact on an entire community

Jun 4·29 min·Episode 25

For years, women disappeared from the streets of Kansas City, many living lives society often overlooked. Behind those disappearances was Terry Blair—a serial killer who preyed upon vulnerable women and believed nobody would notice. In this chilling episode of Among Monsters, Myia Vale examines the crimes, victims, investigation, and eventual capture of one of America's lesser-known but deeply disturbing serial killers.

May 28·18 min·Episode 24

In this chilling episode of Among Monsters, Phillip Friend becomes the center of a horrifying murder-for-hire conspiracy that shattered the quiet town of Willard. What began as an ordinary winter night ended in betrayal, greed, and the brutal execution-style murders of Larry and Claudia Hammer. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

May 21·18 min·Episode 24

Step into the darkness with Among Monsters as Myia Vale explores the terrifying case of Richard Ramirez — the infamous Night Stalker. In 1985, Southern California was gripped by fear as a ruthless killer stalked homes at night, leaving chaos, trauma, and unanswered questions behind. This is the story of one of America's most unpredictable and chilling serial killers.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.